Spring 2014 • English 120 • Section 7225 Instructor Karl Sherlock

Study Guide: Sherman Alexie, Fancydancing

        INSTRUCTION ADMINISTRATION

Official Website of the film The Business Of Fancy Dancing

POEM

The Business of Fancydancing

By Sherman Alexie

After driving all night, trying to reach

Arlee in time for the fancydance

finals, a case of empty

beer bottles shaking our foundations, we

stop at a liquor store, count out money,

and would believe in the promise

of any man with a twenty, a promise

thin and wrinkled in his hand, reach-

ing into the window of our car. Money

is an Indian Boy who can fancydance

from powwow to powwow. We

got our boy, Vernon WildShoe, to fill our empty

wallets and stomachs, to fill our empty

cooler. Vernon is like some promise

to pay the light bill, a credit card we

Indians get to use. When he reach-

es his hands up, feathers held high, in a dance

that makes old women speak English, the money

for first place belongs to us, all in cash, money

we tuck in our shoes, leaving our wallets empty

in case we pass out. At the modern dance,

where Indians dance white, a twenty is a promise

that can last all night long, a promise reach-

ing into back pockets of unfamiliar Levis. We

get Vernon there in time for the finals and we

watch him like he was dancing on money,

which he is, watch the young girls reach-

ing for him like he was Elvis in braids and an empty

tipi, like Vernon could make a promise

with every step he took, like a fancydance

could change their lives. We watch him dance

and he never talks. It's all a business we

understand. Every drum beat is a promise

note written in the dust, measured exactly. Money

is a tool, putty to fill all the empty

spaces, a ladder so we can reach

for more. A promise is just like money.

Something we can hold, in twenties, a dream we reach.

It's business, a fancydance to fill where it's empty.

From The Business of Fancydancing, Hanging Loose Press, 1992

filcritic.com

Hold Me Closer, Fancy Dancer: A Conversation with Sherman Alexie

Posted by Aileo Weinmann

The Business of Fancydancing

filmcritic.com:

How was The Business of Fancydancing made, and how did that allow you to do what you

wanted to with this project-things that you maybe weren't able to do before?

Sherman Alexie:

Well, after Smoke Signals and I saw that an increasing number of American filmmakers were working on

digital too. I just thought, 'Well, I can do this. Somebody give me $12, I'll make a movie,' and that's where

it started from. So I took a video class at 911 Media Arts, a co-op here in Seattle, and it's there that I met

Holly Taylor, who ended up being the [cinematographer] and editor. And most of the crew came from 911.

They all had mostly documentary experience, and hadn't worked on a feature before, and so we all started

off together. So it was quite the socialistic experience.

Why do you want to make movies?

Of course part of it's just simple ego. It's fun. (laughs) I like the attention. But, the biggest thing for me

was, with Smoke Signals we screened it in Minneapolis at the University of Minnesota. This was I think a

year and a half after its initial release. I was speaking at the university and they screened it while I was

there. I just watched a little bit of it and the sound kept going out. It must have been an old print. I was

getting really angry. But there were enough Indians in the crowd who had seen the movie enough times

that they started filling in the dialogue. It was like the Rocky Horror Indian Picture Show, and it was

stunning. You know, I'd never experienced that before. It's not like I could start reading a poem at a

reading and everyone in the crowd starts reading it with me. It's not like I've written 'Stairway to Heaven.'

But for a brief moment in Minneapolis, I felt like I had written 'Stairway to Heaven,' and that was where

the sort of enormous cultural power of movies really hit me on a personal level. So it was a combination of

those things. I love making movies because you become a long part of history of moviemaking. I mean, I'm

no Martin Scorsese or Woody Allen or any of those people, but I get to make movies. (laughs) And I get to

write books. So it's joining an artistic tradition and creating an art form that I just love. I love to be part of

the gang.

Wow, what a great moment that must have been.

Oh, it was! You know, it's a great life I live and there are moments that transcend how much I love my life

on a daily basis, and that one was just-when I'm on my deathbed and thinking of, you know, the five or six

great moments in my life, that'll probably be one of them.

Talk about being a first-time director and what you learned in the course of making The

Business of Fancydancing.

Well one of the reasons I was the director is because I'm not interested in being a director. (laughs) I hate

the sort of cult that surrounds the idea of the director. I mean, it's a hard job and it's a difficult job, but it's

not the only job on the set. So, I really wanted to create an atmosphere where everybody was sort of equal

in the process. So by being the director, I got to, you know, be communistic leader. I guess in some sense I

treated it like film school. I went in with a screenplay, but I went in with a screenplay that was very

strange to begin with, very loosely connected. It was more of a series of scenes, images and poems than a

typical narrative, and on the set I allowed myself to be as free as possible. I would throw the script away, I

would let the actors improvise. And, being a performer myself, I could improvise as the director, and give

them new lines and interact with them in new ways, and create situations that hadn't been thought of in

the screenplay. So I essentially tried to do everything I could think of to test myself, and to shoot every

kind of scene imaginable. You know, I was never sure anybody would see this, so I didn't worry about it.

To try and remove yourself from having control over the process when it's something that is

very important to you, which is adapting your first piece of published work into a story on film-

it must have been an interesting struggle.

Yeah, I'm just as arrogant as the next bastard. But I decided to take my arrogance the other way, right?

'I'm going to be more selfless than anybody ever has.' (laughs) So, you know, inverted it. It's still just as

arrogant, but people like you more. (laughs) It was so much fun, though. I guess I just tried to make it

fun, and not destroy people's lives for the time period in which we were working. It can be so awful making

films-18-hour days, you know. I guess I tried to treat it like it wasn't that important, even though I was

torn emotionally, because the work got pretty autobiographical. And I cried on the set, and other people

cried and we got really close, but I guess-much like an actor's not supposed to think about the end result of

the scene-I tried not to think of the end result of the scene, or a day, or the whole shoot. And that made it

so much easier. I went in thinking, 'this is never going to play anywhere,' and that freed me. So now when

anybody watches it or pays attention, it's great.

The struggle to be an Indian and be a celebrity-talk about how it's portrayed in the film and

how it's been in your own life-the idea that success in white culture equals rejection in Indian

culture, on the reservation.

On a larger scale, every artist lives that life. You know, what is it in Isaiah? A prophet's always a stranger in

his own land. Every artist, I think, goes through that. And for Indians, who come from tribal cultures, it's

even more intense. In tribal cultures every story, every dance step, every move has an owner. The art has

ownership. And you can't sing those songs or tell those stories unless you have explicit permission to tell

them. There are a lot of social rules in an Indian tribe. You know, it's like an Edith Wharton novel on 'the

rez.' But the Western Civ idea of art is, you know, sort of bulldozing your way through everything-that you

have absolute freedom. And so that's a serious dichotomy, and there's always a clash; that being a member

of a tribe and being an artist are often mutually exclusive things. And so I was interested in that conflict,

always have been, I live it. So I wanted to make a movie about it-because nobody had. It's easy to make

the movie people want to see. And it's harder to make the movie people weren't expecting. I tried to make

one people wouldn't expect.

Seymour and Aristotle struggle in their college experience in very different ways. What were

your own experiences at Gonzaga University and Washington State University like, and how

did you make the transition?

Well I think I had both of their experiences. At Gonzaga, where I started, I think I was Aristotle: drunk and

angry, and falling apart. I was always a high-functioning alcoholic in terms of grades; I got out of there with

about a three-point. But I left, because I knew if I stayed there, I'd never finish. I was drinking too hard

and was too angry, and ended up at Washington State, where I became more like Seymour: discovered

writing, discovered a bunch of writer friends, really found my place, started writing and found my future in

that. So at one college I was Aristotle and at the other I was Seymour, and ended up graduating with

honors from [WSU], so my college career was really schizophrenic.

Using alcohol and substance abuse is a major theme throughout this film and your work. Did

leaving alcohol behind and going forward into writing come hand-in-hand for you?

The night after I quit for the last time: you know when you make that decision, and I quit, the next day I

got the acceptance letter from Hanging Loose Press for my first book of poems. So, I was like, 'Oh!' So I

believe in coincidence, but I also believe in interpreting coincidence exactly the way you want to interpret it.

(laughs) So I think it was a wild coincidence-that I decided to let be magic. So since then, they've gone

hand-in-hand, in good ways and bad ways. I mean, just as much as I was addicted to alcohol, I'm addicted

to writing too, and it can be destructive in its own sort of way.

It must be a struggle to have that addictive personality and have a young son who needs so

much attention as well.

Oh yeah, so there's a long history of good writers who are bad parents. I'm working my ass off so that he

doesn't have to write a memoir about me later.

The concept of forgiveness-not just forgiving others, but forgiving oneself-seems really central

to this movie. How did the concept of forgiveness shape the story?

It's funny, I don't get talked about much in these terms, but I'm very Catholic: grew up Catholic, Catholic

father, still am vaguely Catholic (I'm not very good at it anymore). So I think Catholicism and forgiveness

and that aspect of Christianity is a really strong influence on me. And then once you place Catholicism in

the context of me being tribal and the ways in which the church horrendously oppressed Indians, there is a

serious amount of guilt. So, I think it's a combination of guilt and irony and contradiction and forgiveness

that mix up together and become a dominant them in everything I do

And I didn't call it Catholic in the movie, but I think it very much is. Seymour's conflict is very religious and

very spiritual, and that's the way I approached it. Evan [Adams] and I talked about that very much: that,

in some ways, [Seymour]'s a pilgrim.

Homosexuality, the 'other,' and being Indian.

As I've spent more time in urban situations and in the art world, I've made more friends who are gay. So

it's a huge part of my life. My best friend is a lesbian. So part of it is just that my work is starting to reflect

the way in which I live my life. I mean I haven't lived on the reservation in 18 years, so my work is finally

catching up to the diverse urban life in which I live. But artistically, I'm fascinated by the concept of tribes.

And Evan and I, again, when I was writing this movie had a conversation about tribes: the idea of Indian

tribes, and the idea that gay people are a tribe. And we started talking about social rules, and the way

interactions happen, and the way you behave, and the uniforms you wear, and the signifiers, and the ways

in which [Seymour] can jump back and forth between the worlds. That sometimes he feels a lot more

Indian than gay, and vice-versa. That he's never really fully one or the other, but he certainly-depending on

the situation-feels more like one than the other. And so that was just in my head when I started writing.

The idea of what happens when you switch tribes like that. Where are your allegiances? And, especially

when you think about being gay-gay people being universally hated around the world, then you're really

leaving your tribe in all sorts of ways. And so I guess I upped the dramatic impact: not only moving to the

city, not only being a writer, but also being gay. You know, he's leaving his tribe physically, and culturally,

and spiritually, and sexually. Part of me writing about gay people in this movie was a larger social effort. I

knew a lot of Indians will see this move, and there's a lot of homophobes in the Indian world, so I wanted

to slap them in the face a bit.

How do you decide which poems to put in the movie?

Oh man, you know it's funny. By and large, the ones I put in were the ones that-in my performing them-

have gotten the largest audience reaction. But, in Evan's performance of them-which is vastly different

than mine-they became very different poems. So, in some sense, it didn't really matter which poems I

picked, because Evan made them his own, and would've made any of them his own, and I could not have

predicted what they would have become. That was the great part: I mean I picked them for specific

reasons-I wanted this one to be funny, I wanted this one to be sad, I wanted this one to be redemptive,

really concrete ideas-and in the context of the film, and the context of Evan's performance, they became

something else entirely. So, looking back, I thought, 'Oh, it's funny you didn't know that.' In the screenplay

you know its turns, but I felt so possessive of the poems, I thought I knew them better than anybody else

did. But you realize everything you create is always of its own, and that's what happened to the poems. I'm

not sure I'll ever be able to read them aloud again.

What are you working on now?

A book of short stories that will be out in the spring (it doesn't have a title yet). A book of poems that will

probably be out next fall. I just signed on to do a biography of Jimi Hendrix-a very non-traditional biography

and I'm doing some assignment work in Hollywood, raising money, so I can finance the next film. So, you

know, I'm sure you'll probably see my punch-lines in a really bad romantic comedy coming to a theatre

near you (laughs)

I'm not telling you what I'm writing. When there are good movies that come out, I'll tell you. When

they're not, and my name didn't get involved in the credits, I'm not telling a soul.

So how long before we might hear about a 'good movie' of yours?

(Laughs) Well, I'm really hopeful for this one with HBO. I can't talk about it, but keep watching for HBO

news. I've really got my fingers and toes-I'm crossing everything.

Photo credit: Susan Sheridan.